The stoics and socrates

Teach them then or bear with them. There is a potential for serious confusion when we try to assimilate the Stoic view to contemporary epistemology. The antecedent is possible, since Dion will one day be dead. So far the emphasis has been on just one component of the Stoic formulation of the goal or end of life: This was again supposed to show that there could be impressions arising from what is not [sc.

The Stoics distinguish between the signification, the signifier and the name-bearer. The moral virtue relevant to fear, for instance, is courage.

He seemed to think otherwise: Finally, Epicurus not only thinks of this state as a positive one but its pleasure as the preferred state of pleasure. Feelings are such things as appetite, anger, fear and generally those conditions that are accompanied by pleasure and pain. This also implies a very different view of natural science from the modern one: This doctrine has come to be known as the identity of indiscernibles.

In fact, their idea of happiness shares an important feature with the Epicurean, which puts a premium on tranquil pleasures. Human excellence is the psychological basis for carrying out the activities of a human life well; to that extent human excellence is also happiness.

According to Plato, two or three generations before Aristotle, Sophists including Protagoras and Prodicus, the two most famous among them, used to lecture and give speeches at the Lyceum. Socrates at first addresses this issue rather brusquely, saying that someone with a just soul would not embezzle funds, rob temples, steal, betray friends, break oaths, commit adultery, neglect parents, nor ignore the gods.

A bit of reflection tells us that the goal that we all have is happiness or flourishing eudaimonia. Both are elaborated in the Euthydemus.

Three Ideas the Stoics Learned from Socrates

Moreover, Aristippus said that pleasures do not differ from one another, that one pleasure is not more pleasant than another. At bottom what the Stoics are committed to is the two-fold view that it is within our power to avoid falling into error and that there is a kind of impression which reveals to us the world as it really is and which is different from those impressions which might not so reveal the world.

The virtue in each case is a mean between two extremes, the extremes being vices. And of course one of the four virtues examined in the previous section is justice, and one of the three disciplines is that of action—both explicitly prosocial.

However, these distinctions between kinds of dialogues and kinds of Socratic characters are not exclusive; there are dialogues that mix the aporetic and conclusive styles, e.

Ancient Ethical Theory

The Stoic Chrysippus seems to have connected this logically-motivated pathway to fatalism with the question of causal determinism Cicero, 38G. In works like his Academic Books, On the Nature of the Gods, and On Ends he provides summaries in Latin, with critical discussion, of the views of the major Hellenistic schools of thought.

The Stoics did have a concept of chance, but they thought of it much like modern scientists as a measure of human ignorance: So, actions done in accordance with virtue are actions which are done well. Later Stoics like Panaetius 2nd c. Rather, we have the potential to increase our sensitivity to cognitive impressions when they are present.

But when the judgement is vivid and so the commanding faculty is undergoing such a change, one can readily enough see that the characteristic sensations might inexorably accompany the judgement. Any attentive reader of the dialogues must feel that Socrates has now given an answer to the questions that started many of the aporetic dialogues.

A helpful scholiast cf. He seems to have been a rural version of the god, who helped shepherds protect their flocks from wolves. It appears that this is an attempt to work out a set of prima facie duties based upon our natures. Perhaps the thought was that the souls of the wise had a sufficient tensile strength that they could continue to exist as a distinct body on their own.

Three Ideas the Stoics Learned from Socrates

Virtues just are those features which make a thing a good thing of its kind or allow it to perform its function well. The Stoics also developed an account of non-simple propositions. But because the impression and assent are both aspects of one and the same commanding faculty according to the Stoics, they think that we can always avoid falling into error if only our reason is sufficiently disciplined.

Now we can discern the link between morality and happiness. Demetrius above mentioned is also our authority for the statement that Chrysippus was the first who ventured to hold a lecture-class in the open air in the Lyceum.

Perhaps instead they proposed merely that pneuma is the matter of a body at a different level of description. And this literature went on to influence later writers well after the decline of Stoicism, particularly Plotinus C.


As /u/Nanocyborgasm pointed out, Socrates precedes the Stoics and their usage of the word. When the Stoics use daimon/genius, they are using it to refer to one's Reason, which they consider divine.

When the Stoics use daimon/genius, they are using it to refer to one's Reason, which they consider divine. Cynicism and Stoicism are ethical philosophies based on distinguishing between those things in your control from those things not in your control.

Both views stress emotional detachment from the world and emphasize the development of independent character. Aug 21,  · Watch video · Socrates was born and lived nearly his entire life in Athens.

His father Sophroniscus was a stonemason and his mother, Phaenarete, was a midwife. As a youth, he showed an appetite for learning.

Socrates, having laid them to sleep, rose to depart; Aristodemus, as his manner was, following him. At the Lyceum he took a bath, and passed the day as usual. In the evening he retired to. Xenophon’s Socrates was more the Stoic Philosopher, Socrates “always discussed human matters, trying to find out the nature of piety and impiety, honor and dishonor, right and wrong, sanity and lunacy, courage and cowardice, State and statesman”, and all other knowledge that truly good men would seek.

Stoicism. Stoicism originated as a Hellenistic philosophy, founded in Athens by Zeno of Citium (modern day Cyprus), c. B.C.E. It was influenced by Socrates and the Cynics, and it engaged in vigorous debates with the Skeptics, the Academics, and the Epicureans.

The stoics and socrates
Rated 3/5 based on 75 review
Socrates and the Stoics at the Lyceum – How to Think Like a Roman Emperor